The Premier Soccer League (PSL) has long been a symbol of South African sporting pride. However, issues with governance – particularly of smaller clubs – pose a threat to the brand.
The Big Three clubs are Kaizer Chiefs (356.56), Orlando Pirates (7.09) and Easybet favourites Mamelodi Sundowns (1.10). They remain stable brands for now. Yet, other PSL teams face significant challenges.
Royal AM: The Latest In A Long Line
Royal AM has faced numerous controversies. These include delayed player payments and contract disputes. Such problems damage the league’s reputation.
Owner Shauwn Mkhize is facing an ongoing legal battle over an alleged tax debt, while Royal Am were hit with a transfer ban over their non-payment of striker Samir Nurkovic.
Similarly, Tshakhuma Tsha Madzivhandila (TTM) struggled with financial stability. Players often reportedly went unpaid. The non-payment issue involving Cheslyn Jampies led to the liquidation of TTM’s holding company, Equator Holdings, reportedly scuppering a potential multibillion-Rand gas deal. This led to questions about their suitability as a PSL club.
Chippa United also had payment issues – notably with Augustine Kwem, a striker they failed to pay, leading to a transfer ban. Although they have remained in the league, such incidents persist in the South African Premiership. They highlight the need for stronger governance.
Solutions for Better PSL Governance
Improved vetting of club owners is essential. Financial stability should be a prerequisite for ownership. This would prevent unsuitable individuals from running teams.
Another solution is ending the sale of PSL statuses. Allowing clubs to buy and sell statuses undermines the league’s integrity. It often results in poorly managed teams entering the top flight.
Why Change Is Crucial
Although the Big Three provide a strong foundation, the league needs depth. Teams outside the Big Three play a critical role, and their instability affects the overall quality of the PSL.
Chiefs, Pirates and Sundowns are above water for now. Still, the demise of former Soweto giants Moroka Swallows showed that the PSL needs to have strong governance to protect even its most valuable clubs in the league who draw fans to stadiums in droves.
Stronger governance benefits everyone. Players, staff, and fans deserve a well-run league. The PSL must act now to safeguard its future.
